THE PLAUSIBILITY OF IMAGINARY PICASSO 
                                              By V.I. Hambleton
        artssf.com, the independent observer of San Francisco Bay Area theater
                                                                 Weeks starting Feb.. 5, 2009
                                                                 Vol. 11, No. 58
         SAN JOSE---“A Picasso”, now at the San Jose Repertory Theatre in a strong production, is the play to see if you relish a high-stakes verbal chess game where art, Nazi politics, and sex are to be won or lost.
            Author Jeffrey Hatcher ("Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde," "Tuesdays With Morrie") creates an encounter between the flamboyant painter Pablo Picasso and a German woman that lasts, in the play, for the length of the play.   Although the 70-minute encounter itself is fictional, history informs both the encounter and the two characters in the play, and you believe it could have happened, just like that.
 
            It is the autumn of 1941, and we are in Vichy, France.  Paris fell to the Germans a year ago; Picasso, now 60 years old, has elected to remain in Paris, continuing his work of painting and his social life much as before.  Summoned from his favorite café, he has been brought to an underground vault where shelves filled with paintings line one side of the room and a table, chairs, and lamp on the other suggest this is a place for interrogation. 

            Alone for some minutes, Picasso storms back and forth and beats on the door.  Ms. Fischer enters, a beautiful and icy blonde in a fetching black suit, a 1940-perfect black hat and sturdy-but-stylish black shoes.  She works for the German cultural ministry and wants Picasso to authenticate three “confiscated” (as in stolen from their Jewish owners) paintings.  He is suspicious and expresses the doubt that Nazis have any real appreciation of art, preferring paintings of dogs and cats.

            But he proudly identifies the three pictures as his.  As the sparring between the two continues, Ms. Fischer unintentially reveals that an exhibition is planned.  This excites Picasso, and he presses for details.  He wants to attend.  She reluctantly tells him it is a different kind of exhibition—it is to be a showing of “degenerate art”, which will be burned.  Picasso looks at the paintings again and says that on closer examination he can see that they are copies, and initiates a bargaining dialogue with Ms. Fischer.  Softening, she acknowledges that she was, in pre-Nazi times, a student of art, a critic, and an admirer of Picasso.  He talks of the women in his life, connections between his amorous relationships and his art, and says her beauty prompts a desire to draw her.  The somewhat dramatic ending suggests that art triumphs over sex.

            Picasso, who was 5 foot 3 and stocky, is played by James Carpenter, the well-known admired Bay Area actor, who is tall and lanky.  It was a splendid, convincing performance.  Speaking at a Rep-sponsored seminar prior to the play’s opening, he noted the challenge that he faced and said that he was spending hours watching videotapes and old movies of Picasso, noting the way he used his eyes and handled his body.  His study paid off in a convincing stage performance.  Carrie Paff is also a believable female Nazi apparatchik who hides her misgivings (mostly). Jonathan Moscone’s direction and the set design by Erik Flatmo enabled this fine performance.  Meg Neville’s costume designs were perfect.  Ms. Fischer’s appearance prompted a murmur of admiration (recognition?) from the audience.

            “A Picasso” plays at San Jose Rep until February 22.  101 Paseo de San Antonio, San Jose. For info: 408-367-7266, or go online

                                    #

        © V.I. Hambleton 2009
            V.I. Hambleton is a regular theater reviewer for artssf.com.
    These critiques appearing weekly (or sometimes semi-weekly, but never weakly)focus on theater, dance and new musical creativity in performance, with forays into recordings by local artists, and a few departures into books (by authors of the region)as well.
                      #
                   Return to main menu